You’re arguing all over the place here, and none of this is what we’re talking about. One of the reasons why it’s never been necessary to restart the Marvel Universe as DC has multiple times is that we’re careful about not letting the characters age too much–and when one of them gets out of hand, we’ll typically do something to deal with the problem. And saying that there’s something else over there that’s “good enough” for incoming readers is a spurious argument. Like all readers, new readers want the stuff they read to “matter” in the same fictitious way that you do. Setting them up a nice little ghetto and pretending that you’re doing them a service is totally self-serving, and won’t come close to accomplishing the objective.
carlosjdrew liked this