New Brevoort Formspring

  • ask me anything
  • submit a post
  • rss
  • archive
  • "Because he’s the good guy." Really? I guess cops aren't "good guys" when they kill to protect us? Or our grandfathers and fathers when they served in WWII and killed Nazis to protect the world? I guess it's OK that Spider-Man doesn't kill Carnage, because you know, Carnage always comes back to kill more innocent people, so I guess Spidey can sleep well at night knowing that blood is on his hands.
    Anonymous

    Cops don’t go around killing killers–at least the honest and upright ones don’t. Rather, they are focused on apprehending those killers so that they can be tried in accordance with the laws of our nation. There’s noting inappropriate with cops using lethal force when it is warranted in the performance of their duties–but that’s a far cry from them having a “license to kill.” And every use of lethal force by law officers is meant to be investigated to make certain that it was in accordance with the regulations concerning the job. Same thing is true of soldiers; in war, it is acceptable to kill the enemy, but it is not acceptable to, for example, burn down a village of non-combatants because you think they might maybe be harboring some enemy soldiers. There are rules to living in a society, and a hero of any stripe does not put himself above those rules–that’s what villains do.The cops/soldiers kill argument is a bogus one, because it’s all about context. And Spider-Man sleeps soundly, because it’s not his fault if somebody decides to kill people–he is not responsible for the actions of anybody other than himself. For him to decide unilaterally who lives and who dies would make him just as bad as Carnage, who does exactly that.

    • February 6, 2015 (1:15 am)
    • 39 notes
    1. thesunburnstime reblogged this from brevoortformspring
    2. skypig357 reblogged this from brevoortformspring
    3. scottowilliams liked this
    4. ciriacosf liked this
    5. nikoscream said: I only disagree that Peter sleeps soundly hardly at all. I question how much sleep he gets even crime fighting at night, and as guilt ridden over things that are often only tangentially influenced by him, I doubt he sleeps well. Poor Peter.
    6. subsistingonarsenic liked this
    7. foliageeater said: This dude is basically suggesting that every super hero act like the punisher, a character that is a psychopath.
    8. nocommayes liked this
    9. seansonkellboy liked this
    10. danaobera reblogged this from brevoortformspring
    11. danaobera liked this
    12. mattfromitaly liked this
    13. jcaramba liked this
    14. fantastica-sff reblogged this from brevoortformspring
    15. fantastica-sff liked this
    16. thedefaultlocation liked this
    17. alex-a-rey liked this
    18. ittousagi liked this
    19. carlosjdrew liked this
    20. mornmiststuff said: Also if the Sentry tears the guy in half and throws him into the Sun and that doesn’t do the job… What’s Spidey gonna do?
    21. templephoenix liked this
    22. cralspace81 said: Is that Frank Castle???
    23. thewinterbadass liked this
    24. shadowlongknife liked this
    25. thejoshuawilliamson liked this
    26. gregfahlgren liked this
    27. showtime-eric liked this
    28. mgmaz liked this
    29. centipede-damascus liked this
    30. daour liked this
    31. jaymiejess liked this
    32. trevor-ebooks liked this
    33. thelonelyskeptic liked this
    34. brevoortformspring posted this
© 2013–2023 New Brevoort Formspring